Bixby "Bix" Crane finally has a boyfriend to spend the holidays with after meeting Liam over the summer. But as each holiday passes, starting with Halloween, it becomes increasingly clear that Liam just isn't that into him. Left alone at Thanksgiving, Bix reaches out to the man he's always loved, Wyatt Kojowski, who also happens to be the widower of Bix's late cousin, Carl. The three were fast friends in high school and though both cousins loved Wyatt, Carl married Wyatt in the end. Wyatt is alone now too and he invites Bix to Thanksgiving with him. After the best Thanksgiving he's had in years, Bix returns home determined to get Liam to spend Christmas with him, but Liam has other ideas. Finally realizing the truth, Bix ends things with Liam and happily accepts Wyatt's timely invitation to spend Christmas with him. As one door closes for Bix, is another one opening? Or a window maybe. But if he finally opens up to Wyatt about always loving him, will that window end up being a bright window for Christmas?
